Sunday, August 2, 2020

Some sayings of Nagarjuna on emptiness and Buddha nature

Bodhisattva Nagarjuna, the 1st Patriarch
of Jodo Shinshu school
Bodhisattva Nagarjuna said in Praise of the Element of Attributes (words in normal brackets are my own and words in special brackets [..] are the words of Master Dolpopa:

“Homage and obeisance to the element of attributes (Buddha nature with its innate qualities),
Definitely dwelling in all sentient beings,
Which if one does not thoroughly know
One wanders in the three existences.

[Due to being mixed with limitless defilement, the element of attributes is not seen;
For example,][1] just as due to having purified milk
The essence of butter [is seen] without [obstructive] defilement,
So due to having purified [and extinguished] the afflictive emotions [through the Path]
The very undefiled element of attributes [is manifestly seen]. 
(Buddha nature becomes visible only after we extinguish the afflictive emotions. In our case, the Path for purifying afflictive emotions is the Nembutsu of Faith and the place for purifying them is the Pure Land of Amida that we attain after death.)

Just as a butter-lamp dwelling inside a pot
Is not in the least perceived,
So the element of attributes (Buddha nature with its innate qualities) also
Is not perceived inside the pot of afflictive emotions.

[Finally] when the [obstructive] pot has [entirely] been broken,
[The element of attributes] illuminates
[And is seen] to the ends of space.

The element of attributes is not [newly] produced,
[And its entity] never ceases [while one is a sentient
being].
At all times [during the basal state, the path, and the
fruit] it is without afflictive emotions [in its nature]—
In the beginning [in the basal state], the middle [during
the path], and the end [during the fruit primordially]
free from defilement.
(Buddha nature and its innate enlightened qualities is the same no matter we discover it or not. Buddha nature is the Base in the sense that it has always existed and it is the Fruit in the sense that we can discover it after following the Path, which in our case, is the Nembutsu of Faith and birth in the Pure Land.)

Just as a vaidurya gem
At all times is luminous
But dwelling inside an [obstructive] stone
Its light is not manifest,
So the element of attributes obscured by afflictive emotions
Is very undefiled [in its nature],
But its light is not manifest in the cyclic existence [of
afflictive emotions],
Becoming [manifestly] luminous in Nirvana. 
(Nirvana is the discovery of our Buddha nature.)

 [Although the element of attributes is naturally pure, it
is obstructed by obstructing factors;
For example,] even the undefiled sun and moon
Are obscured by five obstructions –
Clouds, mist, smoke,
The face of Rahu[2], and dust and the like.
Similarly, the mind of clear light [which is the nature
of all sentient beings]
Is obscured by five obstructions—
Desire, harmful intent, laziness,
Excitement, and doubt.

[Therefore, although a Buddha in which all qualities
such as the powers and so forth are integrally complete
exists primordially[3] in all sentient beings, the
defilements are extinguished through striving at
the Path clearing away obstructions, but the clear
light is not consumed; for example,]
When a garment [made from a hard mineral] that is
stained
With various defilements and to be cleansed [of defilement]
by fire is put in fire, its stains are burned but it is not.
So, similarly, with regard to the mind of clear light (Buddha nature)
Which has the stains of desire and so forth,
Its stains are burned by the fire of wisdom [on the
Path]
But [since it does not burn the clear light, the qualities
of the clear light do not become non-existent the
way iron is consumed or worn away, and hence]
that [path] does not [burn away] the clear light. 
(The Buddhist Path destroys the stains of blind passions and illusions, but does not destroy the Buddha nature and its innate qualities. The Pure Land of Amida Buddha where we are to be born is like a great fireplace where the stains of defilements are removed and the Buddha nature is revealed automatically.)

All the sutras [such as the Mother Sutras and so forth]
Spoken by the Conqueror that teach emptiness
Overcome the afflictive emotions [of conceiving self ]
But do not diminish [and refute] the essential constituent. 
(The above sutras who teach emptiness do so to help us abandon the idea of a permanent self (ego) in our blind passions and ignorance, but do not say that “the essential constituent” or Buddha nature does not exist.)

[Ultimately the element of attributes cannot be refuted;
For example,] just as water existing on the sphere of earth
Resides [in its nature] without defilement,
So the pristine wisdom inside afflictive emotions
Similarly [always] abides without defilement [never
suitable to be non-existent]. 
(Buddha nature exists and is not stained by our afflictive emotions that cover it since the beginingless past.)

[Though it exists, it is not seen if the obstructions are
not purified;
For example,] just as a child exists in the belly
Of the womb but is not seen,
So the element of attributes covered
With afflictive emotions also is not seen [though always
resident]. 
(We cannot see Buddha nature and its innate qualities – here described as “element of attributes”  as long as we are unenlightened and have blind passions.)

 [A single river has different states due to relation with
other causes and conditions;]
Just as a river in summer
Is said to be ‘warm’
But that [same river] itself in cold season
Is said to be ‘cold,’
So when [the element of attributes is] covered with the
nets of afflictive emotions,
It is called ‘sentient being,’
But when that [element of attributes] itself is separated
from afflictive emotions,
It is called ‘Buddha.’”[4] 
(Buddhas are those who uncovered their Buddha nature from afflictive emotions and illusions, while sentient beings are those whose Buddha nature is still covered by them.)




[1] Brackets [..] are from Master Dolpopa’s [Interlinear Commentary on Nagarjuna’s] Praise of the Element of Attributes.
[2] Rahu is a chief demigod (asura) who sometimes obscures the sun.
[4] The Essence of Other-Emptiness, Taranatha, translated and annotated by Jeffrey Hopkins in collaboration with Lama Lodro Namgyel, Snow Lion Boston & London, 2007, p. 63-67

0 comentarii:

Dharma talks on my youtube channel